Mycelium Link
Mushrooms replacing and remediating synthetic dyes…
Heajoo Lee // Sandra Olave // Erica Schumacker
Many approaches explore natural dyeing but fail to address the current environmental degradation. We are proposing an industrial dyeing method that replaces synthetic dyeing while simultaneously remediating polluted environments in and around industrial dyeing sites.
Welcome to the mushroom dyeing revolution.
INTRODUCTION
Inefficiency in the dying process, poor handling, and insufficient treatment of waste from dyestuff industries has led to toxic dye accumulation and contamination in soil and natural water sources. Over 100,000 commercial dyes exist, contributing to the annual production of over 700,000 tons of dyestuff, of which approximately 15% gets released via wastewater.[1]
Toxic dye discharge harms the ecosystem and human health.
Not only do toxic chemicals affect water and soil quality in the local environments where manufacturing is located, but also complicates the disposal of products through the creation of “monstrous hybrid” products, which uses synthetic dyes to dye natural fibers which could otherwise be composted.[2]
Textile industry requires a revolution that transitions from synthetic dyes to safer, more natural alternatives, while simultaneously addressing existing pollution.
SYNTHETIC DYE
William H. Perkin discovered the first synthetic dye, mauve, in 1856 after which increasingly sophisticated understanding of chemical processes during the industrial revolution contributed to the exponential creation of synthetic dyes and pigments.[3] This period of rapid economic growth also created demand for cost-effective, large-scale production of both textiles and dyes. Synthetic dyes gained popularity because of the range of colors, improvement in colorfastness, and the ability to chemically treat textiles. However, the impact of industrialization has become apparent not only in the environment, but also among the textile industry workers, who are continuously exposed to toxic dyes, solvents, fiber dust, and carcinogenic chemicals, which negatively impact their health.
Despite prohibition of approximately 4000 dyes with known toxicity, mutagenicity, and carcinogenicity, over 100 are still used in the market.[4] Their effects on human and environmental health is wide reaching. Wastewater discharge from dye and textile industries pollutes waterways that serve as a source of drinking water, such as in India, Bangladesh, and China [6, 7]. These pollutants prevent sunlight from reaching photosynthetic organisms which can disrupt the global food chain and cause lasting negative impacts.[5]
The persistence of dye pollution results in bioaccumulation of sediments particularly in fish, crabs and other aquatic life, contaminating the global food chain and directly impacting human consumption .
NATURAL DYE
Civilizations have been experimenting with color found in nature for millennia, using pigment producing plants, minerals, insects, and microorganisms. The most stable reds used in antiquity are based on the 1,2-dihydroxy-anthraquinone chromophore, which could be sourced from parasitic insects like Kermes vermilio, or the roots of madder plants belonging to the family Rubiaceae.[8] For example, Vincent Van Gogh used anthraquinone pigment lakes of madder red, prepared by precipitating the dye extract with an inorganic salt like alum.[9] Red dyes and pigment lakes made from anthraquinones and their hydroxy derivatives have been in use as far back as prehistoric times, and red and purple anthraquinone dyes have been documented in ancient Egypt.[10]
Red dyes and pigment lakes made from anthraquinone and their hydroxy derivatives have been in use as far back as prehistoric times, and red and purple anthraquinone dyes have been documented in ancient Egypt.
Mushrooms and lichen dye was first mentioned in the Bible (Ezekiel 27:7). “Of embroidered fine linen from Egypt they made your sail, which served as your banner. Of blue and purple from the coasts of Elishah they made your awning.’’[11] Their use persisted through the middle ages. The earliest contemporary recipes come from Miriam Rice’s seminal work “Let’s Try Mushrooms for Color,” published in 1976.[12] Over the next few decades, Rice and a local community of enthusiasts continued to experiment, finding they were able to derive a full spectrum of color from reds to violets.
Color and hue are derived from a host of factors such as soil, pH, geography, mordant, extraction type, textile variety, whether the mushroom is fresh, dried, or frozen, growth substrate, and water quality. In addition, one species can elicit several different pigments as it progresses through the dye extraction process.
NATURAL DYE CHEMISTRY
The color in natural pigments is produced via chemical reaction paths called chromophores, which provide electrons paths to bond to oxygen or nitrogen atoms. Water-soluble dye structures have many hydroxyl groups, while dyes require a strong base (like ammonia) to make them more soluble. Mushroom dyes (which contain more acid groups) bind to fabric by forming ionic bonds with amino groups on protein based fibers such as wool and silk. Metal ions from the mordants assist in the formation of these ionic bonds both on the dyes and the fibers.
In natural dyeing, mordants are used to help natural color bind to textiles, improving color fastness and deepening color. Fabric can be pre-mordanted to brighten the color, using Alum (Potassium Alum Sulfate), in a process called blooming. Conversely, Iron (Ferrous Sulfate) can be added after dying, which darkens the color in a process called saddening. Other agents include cream of tartar (tartaric acid) which brightens the color, or Glauber’s Salt (sodium sulfate) which helps prevent streaking. Also playing a large role in color expression is pH, which can be altered with acetic acid (vinegar) creating red, orange, and yellow hues, as well as sodium bicarbonate (baking soda) which increases alkalinity, strengthening blue and violet tones.
The vast majority of these processes and chemicals are ecologically benign, which is a core value for the subculture of dyers and textile weavers who experiment with and develop them.
FUNGI
Fungal microbes play an essential role in the development of earth’s atmosphere providing a symbiotic link for plants to obtain nutrients from the soil, which helped create a habitable environment.
Fungi have the unique ability to breakdown matter, essential for planet earth health and maintenance.
Fungi have been cleaning up the earth for more than 400 million years, and their role is just as important today as it was back then. Fungi could be the missing link to transitioning away from the use of synthetic dyes in the textile industry and toward the use of natural pigments.
These incredible organisms can potentially clean up the existing textile pollution while also providing
a natural replacement for toxic dyes.
FUNGI DYE EXTRACTION
In fungal species, the most common natural dye compounds are Terphenol Quinones, which are enhanced with alkalinity and yield blue, purple, and green hues, and Anthraquinones, which are enhanced with acidity and yield red, orange, and yellow hues. There are about twenty different known anthraquinones from mushrooms (mainly Dermocybe), and sixty anthraquinones from other various molds [12]. Anthraquinones are of particular importance and show the most promise due to their excellent colorfastness and bright hues that have been observed dying both synthetic and natural textiles; this natural alternative could ultimately decrease toxic byproducts otherwise formed during synthetic anthraquinone production [13].
There are three primary types of natural dye extraction from Fungi which all involve the lancing of cell walls in order to increase surface area for chromophore containing organic compounds to be released from the mushroom material into the dye solution.
Method I: Boiling (Dye Bath)
Boil fungi color extraction requires a 1:1 ratio dried mushroom to one ounce of wool. Fungi is added to a pot of hot water and boiled 170–180°F for approximately an hour along with the textile. This allows water-soluble pigment to be freed and then bonded to the fabric.
Method II: Ammonia Extraction
Fungi is placed in a glass container with a 1:1 ratio of household Ammonia (at 30% concentration) and water. The longer the solution sits, the deeper the color that develops.
Method III: Saline Fermentation
Saline fermentation is similar to the Method II process. Mushrooms are submerged into a 2.5% saline solution in a glass container allowing the pigment to develop as a result of fermentation.
Replacing synthetic dyes requires mushrooms that can be grown quickly, economically, and on an industrial scale. While many species meet these criteria, one, Pleurotus ostreatus or “Oyster Mushrooms” are particularly interesting. Pleurotus ostreatus belong to a greater Division of Fungi known as Basidiomycota or “cup fungi.” Basidiomycetes grow abundantly on dead wood, forest or grass because they are potent degraders of cellulose[14]. Varieties of this fungus grow around the world producing a spectrum of vibrant colors from pink to orange, gold, neon green, and bluish grey. “Turkey Tails,” or Trametes versicolor, is one of the most commonly found Basidiomycetes in North America, although variable native species can be found all over the world. As the name versicolor suggests, Turkey Tails can grow in a variety of different colors generally ranging in browns and tans, but occasionally produce orange, blue or even magenta fruiting bodies[15].
By utilizing local fungal varieties, fungal dyes produced in certain cities or countries brand their local mycology into an identifying color. For instance, Jack-O-Lantern or Omphalotus olearius, found only in California produces a fluorescent orange fruiting body. The unique derivative dye identifies the provenance of the resulting fabric, making it unique, precious, and local.
This new model for dyeing subverts the placelessness of global textiles and replaces it with one in which color indicates identity and sustainability for both the consumer and the producer.
Dye Experimentation
The team conducted experiments with Turkey Tails, trametes versicolor, to obtain dyes. As a team, we grew mushrooms at home, purchased dried mushrooms online, as well as foraged locally at a nearby park in Detroit. Both silk and wool, protein fibers materials yielded different tones of tan and brown; however, a few unconventional methods lead to surprising results. By experimenting with multiple extraction methods, the pH, and dye bath contents, numerous colors were successfully obtained.
"Fungi are the grand recyclers of the planet and the vanguard species in habitat restoration."
Paul Stamets
WOOD DECAY FUNGI
Both, Oysters and Turkey Tails are members of the white-rot fungi family, meaning they produce enzymes that degrade and feed on the abundant natural biopolymer lignin. In laboratory experiments, these enzymes have been shown to biodegrade and digest plant fibers, textile effluent, synthetic dyes and less toxic organic compounds. White-rot fungi have been shown to not only decolorize, but also mineralize synthetic dye chemicals through biosorption, biodegradation, bioreaction, and immobilized lignin modified enzymes, however current methods are inefficient, and could be improved with molecular technique advancements to promote efficient enzymatic expression systems [16]. Studies have shown P.ostreatus was able to decolorize dyes including congo red [17], remazol brilliant blue R, poly R-478, crystal violet, and brilliant green [18]. T. versicolor was shown to decolorize rative orange 96, reactive violet 5, and reactive black [19].
MYCOREMEDIATION
Fungi, and particularly wood decay fungi, stand out as a promising natural dye alternative because in addition to providing a source of particularly color fast pigment, they can also be used to bioremediate existing dye pollution. It is this ability to replace AND remediate that makes this project not just about the closure and replacement of synthetic dye factories, but the conversion of factories to natural dyeing and centers of mycoremediation.
While they often are found functioning together with bacteria and an array of other microorganisms, fungi are uniquely suited for breaking down some of the largest molecules present in nature [20]. The main function of fungi in the ecosystem is decomposition, which is performed by fungal mycelium. Wood decay fungus secretes extracellular enzymes and acids that break down lignin and cellulose. These natural compounds are composed of long chain molecules of carbon and hydrogen atoms which share a similar structure to many organic pollutants, allowing the fungal enzymes to degrade them.
In-Situ Mycoremediation
Involves the controlled addition of microorganisms and nutrients, and optimization of environmental factors at the site of contamination. Oxygen and nutrients are supplied to the contaminated soils to stimulate microorganisms to degrade organic contaminants, remediating both polluted soil and groundwater.
Ex-situ Mycoremediation
Involves the removal of contaminated material to a specifically designated area where it is treated by landfarming and composting methods [23]. The labor involved can make this process cost prohibitive, however research remains to be done on whether on-site ex-situ remediation could allow for on-site year-round controlled conditions with minimal transportation.
Transition and Remediation Process
Replacement and remediation will take place in one of two ways. In the first a stable of local mushroom varieties of wood decay fungi will be farmed for dye extraction in soil contaminated with dye chemicals. After breaking down the chemicals, the mushrooms will be harvested and processed for dye extraction. In the second, which involves instances in which the soil is also contaminated with heavy metals which fungus will take up but cannot break down, mushrooms are farmed in uncontaminated soil and become an abundant source or fungal spores to be seeded into the contaminated biome in situ. The fungus that results is then harvested and disposed of annually until remediation is complete.
SUMMARY
The synthetic dye industry continues to harm the environment and human health by leaching toxic chemicals into waterways, groundwater, and soil. Natural dyes are a sustainable alternative, but consumer expectations around color fastness and vibrancy remain a challenge to this transition. Fungi dyeing appears to have superior color fastness and vibrancy to other natural methods. One core species, wood decay fungi, may allow us to produce vibrant, locally unique, color fast dyes, while simultaneously remediating the toxic impact of years of dye pollution. Between the transition to natural dyes in the future, and the remediation of the toxic manufacturing practices of the past, fungi dyeing may just be the mycelium link.
Citations
TEXTILE INDUSTRY AND SYNTHETIC DYE
Singh, Lokendra. "Biodegradation of synthetic dyes a mycoremediation approach for degradation decolourization of textile dyes and effluents." Journal of Applied Biotechnology & Bioengineering 3.3 (2017).
McDonough, William, and Michael Braungart. Cradle to cradle: Remaking the way we make things. North point press, 2010.
Huebner, Karl. "History-150 Years of mauveine." (2006): 274-275. doi:10.1002/ciuz.200690054.
Lellis, Bruno, et al. Effects of Textile Dyes on Health and the Environment and Bioremediation Potential of Living Organisms. Biotechnology Research and Innovation, No Longer Published by Elsevier, 13 Oct. 2019, www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2452072119300413.
Hassan, Mohammad M., and Christopher M. Carr. "A critical review on recent advancements of the removal of reactive dyes from dyehouse effluent by ion-exchange adsorbents." Chemosphere 209 (2018): 201-219.
Textile Industry in India. Source-international Organization, 2017. https://www.source-international.org/featured-textile-industry-in-india. Accessed 10 April 2020.
Simone Doreleijers. The story of Fashion and The Environment. The Well Fashioned, 6 August 2019. https://thewellfashioned.com/the-story-of-fashion-and-the-environment/. Accessed 10 April 2020.
NATURAL DYE
Bechtold, Thomas, and Rita Mussak, eds. Handbook of natural colorants. John Wiley & Sons, 2009.
(a) Kirby, J., ‘Paints, pigments, dyes’, in Medieval Science, Technology, and Medicine – An Encyclopedia, ed. T. Glick, S. J. Livesey & F. Wallis, Routledge, New York (2005) 379- 383.
(b) Burnstock, Aviva, et al. "Comparison of the fading and surface deterioration of red lake pigments in six paintings by Vincent van Gogh with artificially aged paint reconstructions." Proceedings of the 14th Triennial Meeting of the ICOM Committee for Conservation Meeting in Den Haag (I. Vergier ed), Preprint book I, James and James, London. p. 459. Vol. 466. 2005.
(a) Cardon, Dominique and Le Monde des Teintures Naturelles, Editions Belin, Paris, 2003.
(b) Cardon, Dominique. "Natural dyes." Sources, tradition, technology and science (2007): 268.
Kok, Annette. 1966. A Short History of the Orchil Dyes. The Lichenologist. 3: 248-272.
FUNGI DYE EXTRACTION
Rice, Miriam C. Mushrooms for Dyes, Paper, Pigments & Myco-Stix. Mushrooms for Color Press, 2008.
Bechtold, Thomas, and Rita Mussak, eds. Handbook of natural colorants. John Wiley & Sons, 2009.
Varnai, Aniko, et al. "Carbohydrate-binding modules of fungal cellulases: occurrence in nature, function, and relevance in industrial biomass conversion." Advances in applied microbiology. Vol. 88. Academic Press, 2014. 103-165.
Clare. Trametes Versicolor. Curbstone Valley Farm. February 8, 2010. https://curbstonevalley.com/trametes-versicolor/
Jebapriya, G. Roseline, and J. Joel Gnanadoss. "Bioremediation of textile dye using white rot fungi: A review." International Journal of Current, Research and Review 5.3 (2013): 1.
Balaraju, K. Gnanadoss JJ, Muthu S, Ignacimuthu S. Decolourization of azodye (congored) by Pleurotus ostreatus and Laccaria fraterna. The ICFAI Journal of Life Sciences 2008; 2: 45-50.
Knapp, J. and Newby, P. The microbiological decolorization of an industrial effluent containing a diazo-linked chromophore. Water Res 1995; 29(7): 1807–1809.
Novotny, C, Rawat B, Bhatt M, Patel M, Sasek V, Molitors HP. Capacity of Irpex lacteus and Pleurotus ostreatus for decolourization of chemically different dyes. J Biotechnol 2001; 89: 113–122.
Fernandez-Luqueno, et al., 2010. Associated Press. Exotic Mushrooms Grow from Beer Waste in the Cellars of Brussels. NYPOST. Web. February 25, 2020.
Fernández-Luqueño, F., Valenzuela-Encinas C., Marsch R., Martínez-Suárez, C. Vázquez-Núñez, E., Dendooven L. 2010. Microbial communities to mitigate contamination of PAHs in soil—possibilities and challenges: a review. Environmental Pollution Science Research 10:11-30.
Associated Press. Exotic Mushrooms Grow from Beer Waste in the Cellars of Brussels. NYPOST. Web. February 25, 2020. https://nypost.com/2020/02/25/exotic-mushrooms-grow-from-beer-waste-in-the-cellars-of-brussels/.
What Is CBD Distilled and Why Is It Better? The Real CBD. https://www.therealcbd.com/es/que-es-cbd-destilado-y-por-que-es-mejor/?cn-reloaded=1. Accessed 10 April 2020.
CONSULTANT
Dr. Andrew Scarpelli _ a trained molecular biologist with expertise in microbiology and synthetic biology. Andrew is especially interested in where science plays an integral role in society at large, particularly on how biology interacts with art, politics, and cultural trends. He has experience volunteering at Lincoln Park Conservancy, Science Club, the Alliance for the Great Lakes, and as leadership at the CHIditarod. Andrew is one of the founders and lead organizers of ChiTownBio, Chicago's first community biolab.
Dr. Penelope Higgs_Ph.D., Molecular Biosciences, Washington State University, 2001, Postdoctoral Fellow; University of California, Berkeley, 2001-05, Research Group Leader; Max Planck Institute for Terrestrial Microbiology, 2005-2013; Joined WSU faculty, 2013. Her research focus includes developmental biology and regulatory mechanisms of cells.
Site Image Source_ linn-legros / unsplash.jpg, Gigie Cruz-Sy / Greenpeace, Bee Naturalles / unsplash.jpg. Strega, Isabeau, and Raby. “Wiv Luv Non-Profit Water Fest.” Raby Creative, Raby Creative, 8 Oct. 2018, www.rabycreative.com/blog/2018/8/10/wiv-luv-water-fest.